How do Authors’ Perceptions about their Papers Compare with Co-authors’ Perceptions and Peer-review Decisions?

NeurIPS 2021 Author Perception Experiment Alina Beygelzimer, Yann N. Dauphin, Percy Liang, Jennifer Wortman Vaughan(NeurIPS 2021 Program Chairs) Charvi Rastogi, Ivan Stelmakh, Zhenyu Xue, Hal Daumé III, Emma Pierson, and Nihar B. Shah There is a considerable body of research on peer review. Within the machine learning community, there have been experiments establishing significant disagreement across reviewers and across reviewer panels—including at NeurIPS 2021—and active discussions about the state of peer review. But how do author perceptions about their submitted …

authors decisions peer peer-review research review