Auditing Counterfire: Evaluating Advanced Counterargument Generation with Evidence and Style

We present a novel dataset for the controlled composition of counterarguments designed for further applications in argument refining, mining, and evaluation. Our dataset constitutes enriched counter-arguments to posts in the Reddit ChangeMyView dataset that are integrated with evidence retrieved from high-quality sources and generated based on user preferences, adjusting the critical attributes of evidence and argument style. The resultant Counterfire corpus comprises arguments generated from GPT-3.5 turbo, Koala, and PaLM 2 models and two of their finetuned variants (N = …

adjusting advanced applications cs.cl dataset evaluation evidence generated mining novel quality reddit style